ISSB Nature-related Disclosures: EFRAG Consults Until 19 January 2027
On 20 November 2026, EFRAG published a draft comment letter on the ISSB’s Exposure Draft ISSB/ED/2026/1, IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Practice Statement 1 Nature-related Disclosures, and opened a public consultation on it that runs until 19 January 2027. The ISSB nature-related disclosures proposals, issued on 22 October 2026, add requirements on top of IFRS S1 and IFRS S2, and the ISSB’s own comment period closes on 19 February 2027.
Reporting for financial years from 2027 follows the revised ESRS in Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1563 (see our article on the revised ESRS datapoint cut), and the ISSB proposal and EFRAG’s letter leave those ESRS as they are. The stakes sit with groups that report under ESRS and also want to claim compliance with ISSB-based requirements. EFRAG’s letter says ESRS-40a affects more than 1,200 groups worldwide, including groups that will also report under local rules based on ISSB Standards. The draft letter works as an inventory of the extra analysis an ESRS preparer could face if it also applied the Practice Statement as finalised.
Related reading: ESRS-40a for Non-EU Undertakings: The FY2028 Reporting Trigger
Consultation dates for the ISSB nature-related disclosures proposals
| Date | Step |
|---|---|
| 22 October 2026 | ISSB publishes ISSB/ED/2026/1 with a Basis for Conclusions and Accompanying Guidance; 120-day comment period opens |
| 20 November 2026 | EFRAG publishes its draft comment letter and opens its survey |
| 16 and 17 December 2026, 11:00-12:30 CET | EFRAG stakeholder workshops, same content on both days, registration required |
| 19 January 2027 | EFRAG survey closes |
| End January or beginning February 2027 | EFRAG Secretariat analyses the feedback and revises the letter |
| February 2027 | Revised letter goes to the EFRAG SR TEG and SRB for written review |
| 19 February 2027 | ISSB comment deadline |
| Late February or early March 2027 | EFRAG plans to submit its final letter to the ISSB |
How the Practice Statement would sit beside IFRS S1 and IFRS S2
The ISSB chose a Practice Statement over amending IFRS S1 or IFRS S2 or issuing a new standard. The Exposure Draft describes its requirements as incremental to IFRS S1 and IFRS S2 (paragraph IN6), and the status rules follow from that choice:
- An entity can assert compliance with IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standards without applying the Practice Statement (IN7). A jurisdiction need not mandate it to count as an adopter of the ISSB Standards, but it may choose to require it or to make it available on a non-mandatory basis (IN8).
- The date of initial application must be the beginning of an annual reporting period. Paragraph C3 would relieve an entity from providing the disclosures specified by the Practice Statement for earlier periods, and comparative information for those disclosures in its first year (IN11). Paragraph C4 preserves comparative information already required by IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standards.
- An entity could claim compliance only where its disclosures meet the Practice Statement and applicable IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standards (paragraph 35). Paragraphs 36 to 38 would, however, permit specified omissions where disclosure is legally prohibited or information about a nature-related opportunity is commercially sensitive, subject to the stated conditions, without preventing a compliance assertion.
The voluntary label attaches to the decision to apply. Question 11 of the Exposure Draft states that a Practice Statement follows the same due process as a Standard, and that asserting compliance with one has the same effect on financial reporting as applying an IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standard.
EFRAG’s case for a stand-alone standard
EFRAG anchors its letter in recital 43 of the CSRD, Directive (EU) 2022/2464, under which EU sustainability reporting standards should support the ISSB’s work on global convergence, and it aims for the alignment that already exists between IFRS S2 and ESRS E1 on climate.
On form, EFRAG accepts the ISSB’s wish to avoid disrupting IFRS S1 and IFRS S2 implementation and still prefers a stand-alone standard with a phase-in period. The letter asks how an auditor would assure the proper application of IFRS S1 by a company with material nature-related risks and opportunities that chooses not to apply the Practice Statement. It warns that a formally voluntary document could come to be treated by auditors, users and even preparers as a de facto requirement (paragraph 16).
The hierarchy of guidance is the second objection. IFRS S1 says an entity “shall refer to and consider” the SASB Standards; in EFRAG’s reading, ESRS and TNFD core metrics sit in a “may refer to and consider” tier. EFRAG warns that SASB could therefore be perceived as the primary source of nature-related metrics, and notes that some jurisdictions have changed the IFRS S1 reference to SASB from “shall” to “may consider”, which could reduce global comparability (paragraphs 27 and 28 of its letter).
ESRS E2, E3 and E5 metrics: the question EFRAG puts to respondents
Paragraph 30(a) of the Exposure Draft proposes only two cross-industry metrics: the amount and percentage of assets or business activities vulnerable to nature-related risks, and the amount and percentage aligned with nature-related opportunities. Paragraph 33(a) attaches a proportionality mechanism based on reasonable and supportable information available at the reporting date without undue cost or effort.
ESRS contains neither metric. EFRAG notes that ESRS requires anticipated financial effects for climate in ESRS E1-11, while ESRS E2 to E5 carry no topical specification of ESRS 2 paragraph 27, so the two metrics may require ESRS preparers to provide additional information.
Revised ESRS 1 paragraphs 125 to 127 provide targeted transitional relief for specified disclosures, including certain quantitative information about anticipated financial effects under ESRS 2 paragraph 27 and ESRS E1-11. For wave-one undertakings, that relief can extend to financial years before 2030; for other undertakings, it can cover their first four reporting years, subject to exceptions. EFRAG’s letter asks the ISSB to consider a similar phase-in for the two metrics (paragraph 25), and the ISSB separately invites views on additional transition relief in Question 13(b).
On metrics, EFRAG goes further than the ISSB. It suggests adding cross-industry metrics taken from ESRS: pollutant emissions to air, water and soil from ESRS E2-4; water consumption, including in areas of water stress, and related withdrawal, discharge, reuse and storage figures from ESRS E3-4; waste diverted from and directed to disposal from ESRS E5-5; and, for consideration, resource inflows from ESRS E5-4. A note to constituents gives the rationale: nature would then reach the level of interoperability that greenhouse gas emissions already have between IFRS S2 and ESRS E1. The same note records that some EFRAG SRB members disagreed, citing extra cost and complexity for companies and consistency with the financial materiality approach of the ISSB Standards. The survey asks respondents whether they agree.
EFRAG attaches a condition to its own suggestion: only metrics aligned with ESRS should be added, because metrics misaligned with ESRS could make interoperability difficult for preparers that want to comply with both (paragraph 34).
Where an ESRS preparer could face extra work
The following proposed disclosures could require additional analysis from an ESRS preparer that also elects, or is required by its jurisdiction, to apply a final version of the Practice Statement. They do not amend ESRS or create obligations for ESRS-only reporters. The comparison below concerns the ISSB proposal and the existing ESRS requirements, as EFRAG’s letter draws it:
| Draft Practice Statement provision | EFRAG’s comment relative to ESRS |
|---|---|
| Paragraph 20: use nature-related scenario analysis to assess resilience | ESRS 2 SBM-3 paragraph 33 requires a resilience disclosure but not the use of scenario analysis; EFRAG asks for closer alignment with ESRS and TNFD (paragraphs 85 and 87) |
| Paragraphs 27 and 28: whether and how scenario analysis informs the assessment of nature risks and the identification of nature opportunities | Not required by ESRS (paragraphs 83 and 84) |
| Paragraph 15(a): how governance bodies and management take location-related considerations into account | Not required in ESRS (paragraph 57) |
| Paragraph 26(b): whether and how value-chain locations are considered in identifying, assessing, prioritising and monitoring nature risks and opportunities | Granularity could go beyond ESRS IRO-1 (paragraph 58) |
| Paragraph B32: “sensitive locations”, aligned with the TNFD | Criteria differ from ESRS “biodiversity-sensitive areas” and may lead to different outcomes (paragraph 59) |
| Paragraph 34(b) examples, such as the value-chain locations a target covers | EFRAG deems the paragraph 34 target description covered by ESRS 2 paragraph 51, but says the 34(b) examples outline specifics ESRS does not address, such as the locations of assets or activities in the value chain included in a target; it questions whether preparers and auditors would treat the examples as requirements (paragraph 98) |
EFRAG also asks the ISSB to add provisions ESRS already has. It proposes wording for paragraph 19(a) that would require information on any nature-related transition plan, to align with IFRS S2 and ESRS E4-1, and it wants the targets provisions, through requirements or guidance, to address the mitigation hierarchy, biodiversity offsets and ecological thresholds.
Indigenous Peoples, local communities and the engagement trigger
According to EFRAG, the draft is the first ISSB document with sector-agnostic disclosures on social topics (paragraph 61). Its requirements on Indigenous Peoples, Local Communities and affected stakeholders are centred on the entity’s interactions with them, including engagement. In EFRAG’s view, disclosure should start from whether people are or may be affected, and an absence of engagement may itself be material information for users (paragraph 71).
EFRAG therefore recommends removing “if any” from paragraph 18(c), dropping the term “interactions”, and defining “engagement”, “Indigenous Peoples” and “Free, Prior and Informed Consent” in line with the ESRS glossary (paragraphs 48, 70 and 71).
Responding to EFRAG, to the ISSB, or to both
EFRAG collects views through the two December workshops and an online survey; the survey’s PDF version is a convenience copy, and EFRAG considers only submissions made online. It targets companies subject to, or preparing for, CSRD sustainability reporting under ESRS and stakeholders with experience of nature-related disclosures under the ISSB or ESRS frameworks. Responses feed EFRAG’s European position, as planned in the EFRAG agenda consultation for 2027-2029, which lists answering ISSB consultations with draft comment letters and stakeholder feedback.
The ISSB consultation is a separate channel. The ISSB prefers responses through its own survey and accepts a comment letter instead, uploaded as an editable PDF. Evidence a preparer wants on the ISSB’s public record, on the paragraph 30(a) metrics or on scenario analysis, goes there by 19 February 2027.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will EFRAG’s final letter reach the ISSB before the 19 February 2027 deadline?
EFRAG’s own timetable places its submission in late February or early March 2027, after the date printed on the Exposure Draft. The EFRAG news release does not say whether the ISSB has agreed to a later filing.
Are survey responses published?
By default EFRAG publishes all written submissions and the names of contributors, and respondents can ask for confidentiality. Comments sent to the ISSB go on its public record unless the respondent requests confidentiality, which the ISSB says it will not normally grant without a good reason, such as commercial confidentiality.
Can a group that applies only IFRS S2 under its local rules use the Practice Statement?
As drafted, an entity may apply the Practice Statement only if it applies both IFRS S1 and IFRS S2 at or before the date of initial application (paragraph IN10 and Question 13). EFRAG notes that some jurisdictions have adopted only IFRS S2 (paragraph 15 of its letter). A group under such a regime would need IFRS S1 as well.
Related Articles
- ESRS-40a for Non-EU Undertakings: The FY2028 Reporting Trigger: EFRAG’s draft standards for certain non-EU undertakings and when reporting starts.
- Revised ESRS: The 60% Datapoint Cut Facing CSRD Reporters: what the July 2026 revision of ESRS changes for CSRD reporters.
- EFRAG Agenda Consultation 2027-2029: The 15 February 2027 Deadline: EFRAG’s proposed sustainability reporting workplan.
Sources and References
- EFRAG news release on the draft comment letter and public consultation (20 November 2026): EFRAG
- EFRAG Draft Comment Letter on ISSB Practice Statement Exposure Draft (November 2026): PDF
- EFRAG consultation survey: online survey
- ISSB Exposure Draft ISSB/ED/2026/1, IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Practice Statement 1 Nature-related Disclosures (October 2026): PDF
- IFRS Foundation news release (22 October 2026): ISSB consults on proposals for nature-related disclosures
- ISSB consultation page and comment letters: IFRS Foundation
- Directive (EU) 2022/2464 (CSRD), recital 43: EUR-Lex
- Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1563 of 3 July 2026 (revised ESRS): EUR-Lex
- EFRAG Request for Input, sustainability reporting agenda 2027-2029 (October 2026): PDF
What to settle before EFRAG’s survey closes on 19 January 2027
For a group reporting under both ESRS and ISSB-based rules, the most useful input is evidence from its own data: whether the two paragraph 30(a) figures can be built from existing ESRS E2 to E5 work, and whether ESRS E2, E3 and E5 metrics belong in the Practice Statement. The EFRAG workshops run on 16 and 17 December 2026, the EFRAG survey closes on 19 January 2027, and comments to the ISSB are due by 19 February 2027.
Disclaimer: The information on RegReportingDesk.com is for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal, regulatory, tax, or compliance advice. Always consult your compliance officer, legal counsel, or the relevant supervisory authority for guidance specific to your institution.
