IFM Self-Assessment Questionnaire: CSSF Review of 2021-2023 Answers
On 20 November 2026 the CSSF published a thematic review of the self-assessment questionnaires that Luxembourg investment fund managers (IFMs) filed under Circular CSSF 21/789, as amended by Circular CSSF 23/839. It analyses the IFM self-assessment questionnaire answers for 2021, 2022 and 2023 and pairs the findings with recommendations, following the questionnaire’s own sections from shareholding and own funds through delegation, IT and branch reporting.
The answers carry board-level accountability. Circular 21/789 makes the management body or governing body and the senior management responsible for the questionnaire’s content, and requires them to review and validate it before it goes to the CSSF. The IFM’s approved statutory auditor (réviseur d’entreprises agréé, REA) then runs procedures defined by the CSSF on those answers in a separate report. The CSSF closes the review’s context section by inviting all IFMs to compare their own self-assessment with the findings and, where relevant, to take the necessary corrective measures.
Timing gives that invitation a practical edge. For a 31 December year-end, the next questionnaire is due by 30 April 2027 under the circular’s four-month rule (my count), so the review arrives while the FY2026 answers are being assembled.
Related reading: CSSF Illiquid Asset Valuation Review: What Luxembourg IFMs Must Address
The IFM self-assessment questionnaire review: scope and dates
Nothing in the review amends Circular 21/789 or moves a filing deadline. Its evidence base is the questionnaires for 2021 to 2023. The CSSF notes that it updated the questionnaire during the first two years of application to clarify certain subjects, and that one major change, for questionnaires to be submitted as from 31 December 2024, concerned IFMs also subject to the MiFID II Directive. The data stop before that change, so the review contains no findings on the MiFID-related questions.
The operative dates, old and new:
- December 2021: Circular CSSF 21/789 published. It applies to financial years ending on or after 31 December 2021, the first year of application.
- 26 July 2023: Circular CSSF 23/839 amends Circular 21/789 (changes below).
- 15 November 2023: the CSSF announced limited updates to the IFM questionnaire for the 31 December 2023 year-end, filed in the Collective Investment Sector Reporting Tool (CISERO) module of eDesk.
- Questionnaires to be submitted as from 31 December 2024: the MiFID II-related change the review mentions.
- 20 November 2026: thematic review published, in English and French.
- Every year: questionnaire within four months after the financial year-end; REA separate report and management letter within seven months, both submitted by the IFM’s responsible persons; internal audit summary report within five months, as the review reminds.
- For a 31 December 2026 year-end (my count): 30 April 2027 for the questionnaire, 31 May 2027 for the internal audit summary report, 31 July 2027 for the separate report and the management letter.
The four-month and seven-month rules sit in sections 3, 4.2 and 4.3 of the circular. Sections 3 and 4.3 add that the CSSF may review these deadlines, so the counts above should be checked against the CSSF’s announcement for each reporting campaign.
Who files the questionnaire
Section 1 of the circular reaches Chapter 15 management companies (including those that are also registered or authorised AIFMs), authorised AIFMs, self-managed investment companies (SIAGs) and internally managed AIFs (FIAAGs), plus branches in both directions: Luxembourg branches of IFMs under Chapter 17 of the UCI Law and foreign branches of Luxembourg IFMs.
The distinction that changes the answer sits inside Chapter 16. A management company under Article 125-2 that is also an authorised AIFM files the questionnaire. A management company under Article 125-1 does not, and is caught only by the circular’s points on the statutory audit and the management letter. Chapter 18 management companies are outside the circular altogether. Banks answer a different questionnaire, the Long Form Report self-assessment questionnaire under Circular CSSF 22/821, with its own deadlines and modules.
What Circular 23/839 changed in 2023
The 26 July 2023 amendment brought Article 125-1 management companies within the circular for two points only, the statutory audit (point 4.1) and the management letter (point 4.2); they stay outside the questionnaire. Its tracked changes also deleted the earlier requirement for IFMs to transmit information spontaneously to the CSSF when the REA issues a modified audit opinion. It repealed Circulars CSSF 18/698 and 19/708 as regards the procedures for transmitting the management letter, so the transmission rule is the one in Circular 21/789: once the REA has drawn up the letter, the IFM’s responsible persons submit it through the eDesk portal. A smaller edit moved first-year responsibility for submitting the separate report from the REA to the IFM’s responsible persons.
Own funds answers: quarterly checks, the guarantee and PII
Section I is where the review is most specific about how answers went wrong. On coverage, 87% of IFMs in 2021 and 95% in 2023 verified monthly or quarterly that eligible capital covered required own funds; a minority checked less often. Point 44 of Circular CSSF 18/698 requires procedures that let the IFM calculate required own funds and available eligible capital at any time, and the CSSF expects the verification at least quarterly. The review’s reminder is firmer: IFMs must comply with the own funds requirements at all times and carry out the necessary controls on a quarterly basis at least.
Investment of own funds showed a similar split. In 2021, 88% of IFMs regularly checked that own funds sat in liquid or short-term convertible assets without speculative positions; in 2023 the figure was 92%. The CSSF reiterates the controls required under Article 102(1)(b) of the UCI Law and Article 8(8) of the AIFM Law, and repeats from its FAQ on the submission of closing documents and financial information by managers that “à recevoir” items (amounts receivable) are not liquid assets for the own funds rules.
The guarantee finding documents a misreading by the filers themselves. Article 102(1)(a) of the UCI Law and Article 8(6) of the AIFM Law allow a guarantee that relieves the IFM of providing up to 50% of the additional own funds amount. Few IFMs use it, some did not notify the CSSF that they did, and some answered the guarantee question with their professional indemnity insurance (PII). The CSSF states that the questionnaire’s guarantee item relates only to the additional own funds requirement and that it updated the questionnaire accordingly. Under point 34 of Circular 18/698, providing or withdrawing the guarantee, or changing its conditions, requires prior notification to the CSSF.
For AIFMs, slightly more than half covered professional liability risks through PII, a share the review describes as trending down over the three years. Three reminders follow, all tied to Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) No 231/2013. The AIFM monitors regularly that the policy meets Articles 12 and 15. Under Article 15(2), any agreed defined excess must be fully covered by own funds and added to required own funds. And the two routes, additional own funds or PII, cannot be combined; a tooltip in the questionnaire now says so.
One reporting consequence follows from that last point. An AIFM that holds a policy but has chosen to cover professional negligence risks with own funds must not report the insurance in the questionnaire, and any change of route has to be notified to the CSSF.
Substance answers: premises, staff and the end-of-day backup
Over the three years, access to the premises of about 93% of IFMs was secure and restricted to their staff. At the rest, people outside the staff, such as persons linked to the IFM’s group, had access. Citing point 152 of Circular 18/698, the CSSF highlights the importance of securing the premises and limiting access to staff and, where applicable, to persons the IFM has authorised in advance (its examples are internal audit, IT team members and group management), with mitigation measures for confidentiality, conflicts of interest and security where that is not the case.
Headcount grew. Staff employed in Luxembourg rose from 6,528 in 2021 to 7,708 in 2023, an 18.1% increase; with IFM branches included, from 8,404 to 10,532, or 25.3%. The average IFM went from 21 to 26 employees in Luxembourg (about 27 to 35 with branches) and from 3 to 4 managers. All IFMs had at least three full-time equivalents performing key functions as point 595 of Circular 18/698 provides.
The CSSF attaches a clarification that bears directly on the substance questions: the key functions are those laid down in point 1(15) of Circular 18/698, and the persons who count are not limited to people in management positions.
The accounting function finding carries a newer cross-reference. Most IFMs organise accounting in line with section 5.1.3 of Circular 18/698: policies giving a true and fair view, accounting documents available or electronically accessible at the Luxembourg head office, and procedures meeting points 150 and 151. Where the accounting system is hosted outside Luxembourg, the CSSF now cites sub-chapter 1.3 of Circular CSSF 25/882, the circular on ICT third-party services for DORA entities, as amended by Circular 26/915 (background in our note on Circular CSSF 26/915 and the DORA circulars).
The requirement it restates is specific. At the end of each day the IFM must hold a secure backup of all end-of-day accounting positions, client positions included, in a readable format that allows a balance sheet, a profit and loss account and client positions to be produced autonomously. The backup must be stored at the IFM’s premises in Luxembourg, at a group entity in the EEA, or at another EEA service provider that is not the one hosting the accounting system.
Governance answers: depositary links, SICAV boards and monthly meetings
In 2023 a very limited number of IFMs had management body members who were also employed by the depositary of one or more funds they manage. Those IFMs held both an AIFM authorisation and a Chapter 15 authorisation and had adopted a dual structure that met the depositary independence requirements of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2016/438 on the UCITS side, as detailed in Section 5 of the CSSF’s FAQ on the UCI Law. For the AIFM side the CSSF strongly recommends that AIFMs comply with the UCITS Directive’s independence provisions.
The SICAV overlap finding is larger. One fifth (20%) of IFMs do not follow the recommendation in point 65 of Circular 18/698 that the management body of the IFM and that of a UCI in corporate form should not mainly consist of the same persons. Point 65 stays a recommendation, and the review raises the stakes through conflicts of interest. The CSSF requests IFMs to review the composition of both bodies, names a different board composition or one or more independent directors on either board as mitigation, and states that this type of conflict must at least be entered in the IFM’s conflicts of interest record with appropriate mitigation.
Mandates and meetings close the section. In 2023, 96% of IFMs controlled the mandates held by their board members, which points 67 and 68 of Circular 18/698 tie to identifying conflicts and to each member giving the role enough time. 84% of IFMs held executive committee meetings at least monthly, up from 77% in 2021. Point 100 requires conducting officers to hold periodic meetings in Luxembourg at least monthly, or more often depending on the IFM’s size, organisation and activities. The review repeats what the CSSF’s 2023 Annual Report already said: these meetings must be documented in writing, with the agenda and the minutes recording the executive committee’s decisions and measures.
Risk management answers: combined roles, valuation and stress tests
In 2023 the person responsible for the permanent risk management function (PRMF) was also the conducting officer in charge of that function at 65% of IFMs (67% in 2021). The CSSF leaves the combination to the IFM’s own judgement under the four-eyes principle: the IFM has to assess whether it is appropriate from an organisational and conflicts of interest perspective, given the nature, scale and complexity of its activities. At those IFMs the risk management function averaged three persons over the period.
Valuation independence is framed by Article 14 of the AIFM Law, under which the risk management function must be independent from the business units. In 2023, where risk management and valuation sat under the same conducting officer, 94% of AIFMs had mitigation measures in place. The CSSF reiterates that AIFMs must keep risk management and valuation independent of each other, and refers to point 533 of Circular 18/698, which recommends separating the two functions where an AIFM predominantly manages complex and illiquid strategies and instruments.
A precise organisational rule sits in the internal audit paragraph of this section. The review reports that in most cases the executive committee performs the internal audit function collectively. It states that the person responsible for the risk management function (written “RRMF” in the English text and RFGR in the French version) cannot be in charge of internal audit and works under the direct responsibility of the conducting officer in charge of risk management, unless that person also acts as that conducting officer and internal audit reports to the executive committee collegially.
Circular CSSF 18/698 supplies the governing rules. The internal audit function must operate independently (points 262 and 263). Under point 286 of Circular CSSF 18/698, one member of senior management must be responsible for internal audit. That responsibility cannot be assigned to the conducting officer responsible for risk management, compliance or AML/CFT compliance, and the internal audit function must report to senior management as a whole.
Circular CSSF 18/698 distinguishes the responsibility for the permanent risk management function from responsibility for internal audit. Under points 197 and 200 to 201, the PRMF ordinarily works under the conducting officer responsible for risk management, although the conducting officer may also act as PRMF where the proportionality conditions are met. Neither the PRMF nor the conducting officer responsible for risk management may be responsible for internal audit. My reading is that collegial reporting to senior management does not by itself let the PRMF or the conducting officer for risk management take responsibility for internal audit, so an IFM relying on the review’s exception should confirm its arrangement with the CSSF.
A minority of IFMs reported that risk management did not cover branches, representative offices, agencies and subsidiaries. Citing points 168, 569 and 576 of Circular 18/698, the CSSF says the function must cover those entities and that the description of the risk management process must be appropriate and proportionate to their activities. Nearly all IFMs had the board validate each fund’s risk profile and the executive committee adopt each fund’s limit system, and nearly all documented the function’s interventions; under point 195 the CSSF underlines the importance of documenting every intervention and stresses that the PRMF should follow up its recommendations on identified issues effectively and report on them regularly to senior management and the board.
Stress testing drew the longest list of legal anchors. Some IFMs ran neither periodic stress tests nor scenario analyses. Point 205 of Circular CSSF 18/698 reminds IFMs that they must, where appropriate, conduct periodic stress tests and scenario analyses. For UCITS management companies, the point cites Article 45 of CSSF Regulation No 10-4 for the risk measurement and management requirements. For AIFMs, Article 45(3)(c) of Delegated Regulation (EU) No 231/2013 requires periodic appropriate stress tests and scenario analyses, while Article 48(2) requires liquidity stress testing at least annually.
Articles 43 of CSSF Regulation No 10-4 and 40 of Delegated Regulation 231/2013 primarily address risk-management policies. The risk management policy must also contain the techniques, tools and arrangements of the liquidity risk management procedure, applied where appropriate, that keeps each fund’s liquidity profile consistent with its redemption policy, under Article 45 of CSSF Regulation No 10-4, Article 15 of the AIFM Law and Articles 46 to 49 of Delegated Regulation 231/2013. The same function is the subject of ESMA’s common supervisory action on the risk management function, which runs through 2026 and 2027.
Compliance and internal audit: the CMP, reporting cadence and the audit plan
Over 90% of IFMs run the permanent compliance function internally. In more than half of those, the person responsible for compliance (PRCF) is also the conducting officer in charge of it, and that overlap grew from 54% in 2021 to 63% in 2023. The CSSF applies the same four-eyes reasoning it used for risk management. In 2023 two-thirds of IFMs had between two and five people in the function, and the CSSF cites point 178 of Circular 18/698: all staff in control functions, conducting officers included, must keep their knowledge current and receive relevant training.
All IFMs reported a compliance policy, procedures and charter in 2023 and confirmed points 163, 164, 165, 171, 173 and 227; since the end of 2023 all have complied with points 229 and 230. The review then sets expectations of its own. The CSSF expects each IFM to have a compliance monitoring plan (CMP) adopted on a risk-based approach, listing the monitored activities, the risk assessed for each and a timetable for a multi-year programme. At a minimum the CMP covers governance and procedures, administration of managed funds, the functions in point 94 of Circular 18/698, depositaries and supervision of delegates, and shows where compliance relies on monitoring performed by other departments. The CSSF also expects the PRCF to report at least monthly to senior management and at least quarterly to the board, with the report discussed and documented at those meetings.
For a few IFMs the compliance function did not cover branches, representative offices, agencies and subsidiaries, and the CSSF reminds that it must (points 168 and 576). With reference to point 233 on the function’s responsibilities, it underlines the importance of consulting compliance beforehand on major strategic decisions such as launching a new type of activity, product or business relationship, or expanding the IFM’s transactions internationally.
Internal audit is mostly outsourced: 87% of IFMs used a specialised external firm throughout the three years. The CSSF observed a quality difference between reports from specialised firms and reports drawn up by the internal audit function of the IFM’s group, without quantifying it. Charters were in place with very few exceptions, and at least 99% of IFMs assessed the elements listed in point 270 of Circular 18/698.
The audit plan is where answers diverged. Point 287 of Circular 18/698 requires internal audit work to follow a plan covering several years, generally three. In 2023, 20% of IFMs had a plan over another period: 16% one year, 3% four years and 1% five years. The CSSF recommends that IFMs with a plan longer than three years move to a three-year plan, and restates point 288: the plan is discussed with and submitted to senior management for approval, confirmed by the audit committee where there is one, and finally approved by the board.
More than 95% of IFMs confirmed that the internal audit summary report covered the elements in point 299. Point 299 of Circular CSSF 18/698 recommends that the internal audit summary report cover the listed topics over several years, generally three. Separately, points 298 and 301 require an annual internal audit summary report and its submission to the CSSF within five months after year-end.
Point 300 specifically requires the report to cover compliance with AML/CFT professional obligations annually. Article 44(1) of CSSF Regulation No 12-02 requires internal audit to test and assess AML/CFT policies and procedures independently, and Article 44(2) requires it to report on compliance with those policies and procedures at least annually. Where the group’s internal audit function serves the IFM, it must cover the IFM’s activities, with a summary report dedicated to the IFM and no other group entity.
Procedures, product approval, conflicts and remuneration
All AIFMs confirmed a complaints procedure in each of the three years and, in 2023, a conflicts of interest policy and a remuneration policy. Procedures on personal transactions, rules of conduct and the exercise of voting rights were less consistent. The CSSF restates the anchors for each:
- written procedures on personal transactions, with the list of notified or identified personal transactions available at the Luxembourg head office (Article 14 of CSSF Regulation No 10-4, Article 63 of Delegated Regulation 231/2013);
- acting in the best interests of the managed UCIs and their investors (Article 111 of the UCI Law, Article 11 of the AIFM Law, point 386 of Circular 18/698);
- a strategy for when and how voting rights attached to portfolio instruments are exercised, to the exclusive benefit of the UCI and its investors (Article 23 of CSSF Regulation No 10-4, Article 37 of Delegated Regulation 231/2013).
A precise and clear manual of procedures, describing internal functioning, task allocation and reporting lines, must be available at the head office, accessible to staff and kept up to date (points 357 and 358 of Circular 18/698).
Around 20% of IFMs do not give approval for the launch of new products and new relationships. The CSSF reiterates that every IFM must have arrangements to identify and assess risks, ML/TF risks included, linked to launching a UCI, compartment or new asset type, entering any new business relationship (a new UCI initiator, a delegate, or a relationship in discretionary management and ancillary services), and moving into new markets or geographic areas. It points to Chapter 9 of Title III of the Joint Guidelines on ML/TF risk factors adopted by Circular CSSF 21/782, points 16.5 to 16.12. The arrangements rest on procedures and an approval committee (points 354 and 355 of Circular 18/698), with consultation of risk management and compliance and escalation if they disagree, and the IFMs concerned are requested to put an approval procedure in place.
Every IFM keeps a conflicts of interest record (Article 22(1) of CSSF Regulation No 10-4, Article 35 of Delegated Regulation 231/2013). In 2023, 35% of IFMs identified no conflicts at all, 60% identified between 1 and 25, and 5% more than 25.
The CSSF then lists situations that may constitute conflicts. Among them are board overlap with a corporate UCI, risk management and compliance combined in one person without supporting staff, preferential investment in group products, and acquisitions of securities issued by an affiliated company. For IFMs running products set up on third parties’ initiative, it names business dependence on those clients as a conflict to assess (our guide to the CSSF white-label business notification covers the related filing). The CSSF requests all IFMs, and in particular those that identified none, to review and update their records in light of those examples.
The review also encourages IFMs managing UCIs marketed to retail investors to designate at least one independent director, except where stricter regulatory provisions apply. The English text places that director on the IFM’s “governing body or their servicer”, which reads oddly. The French version refers to the IFM’s “organe directeur” or “organe de gestion”, its governing body or management body, and the review states that the French text prevails in case of discrepancies. The verb in both versions is “encourages”.
On remuneration, all IFMs confirmed a policy that complies with Articles 111a and 111b of the UCI Law or Article 12 of the AIFM Law. In 2023, though, 6% of IFMs (10% in 2021) said that control-function staff pay was linked to the performance of the activities they controlled, or was set by other criteria that compromised the objectivity of their work. The CSSF’s reminder list includes a proportionate approach, a pay structure that avoids excessive risk-taking and protects control-function independence, identified staff categories, risk-adjusted performance indicators, and variable pay that can be reduced or cancelled for underperformance or poor risk management.
Delegation answers: the register the CSSF describes
Most IFMs have a procedure covering delegation and sub-delegation. The CSSF’s point, citing point 422 or 423 of Circular 18/698, is that the requirements for delegating functions apply mutatis mutandis when a delegate sub-delegates, and at every further level, so sub-delegation belongs in the IFM’s framework procedure.
For critical or important delegations and sub-delegations, the CSSF then recommends a monitoring tool that records, for each (sub-)delegation:
- a unique identifier;
- key information on the (sub-)delegate: names, country of registration, LEI and contact details;
- key contract terms: start date, next renewal date, end date and/or notice period, governing law, competent jurisdiction and annual cost;
- the type of delegated function (IT, control function, portfolio management and so on) and a short description of the delegated tasks;
- assessment tracking: date and conclusion of criticality assessments, date of the next planned due diligence, and the person or body at the IFM that approved the (sub-)delegation.
The CSSF calls a register listing these elements good practice.
A large majority of IFMs run a multi-year due diligence plan on delegates, updated on a risk-based approach. Measured across the due diligence performed, 55% took place every three years, 25% every two years and 20% every year.
For portfolio management, the main delegate locations in 2023 were, in descending order, the United Kingdom, the United States, Switzerland, Germany and France. In 99% of cases the delegate was authorised or registered for asset management. The CSSF reiterates that an AIFM planning to delegate portfolio management to an undertaking that is neither authorised or registered for asset management nor subject to supervision must request prior authorisation from the CSSF under Article 18(1)(c) of the AIFM Law, and points back to its earlier feedback report on the delegation of the portfolio management function.
IT answers and the “Not applicable” box
On IT policy the numbers are high: 95% of IFMs in 2021 and 99% in 2023 confirmed policies and procedures covering the organisation of the IT function, IT security, the business continuity plan and the disaster recovery plan, with reference to Article 5(2) of CSSF Regulation No 10-4 or Article 57(2) of Delegated Regulation 231/2013.
The IT systems questions split by activity. About 70% of IFMs managing portfolios internally confirmed, consistently over the three years, that they regularly assessed their systems and had IT systems suitable for timely and proper recording of each portfolio transaction (Articles 8 and 15 of CSSF Regulation No 10-4; Articles 58 and 64 of Delegated Regulation 231/2013). For the 30% that answered otherwise, the 2023 explanations showed that most used less elaborate systems suited to low transaction volumes, while others had not documented the assessment.
The review’s clearest example of a field answered wrongly comes from the UCI administration question. About 65% of IFMs performing registrar and/or NAV calculation and accounting functions gave the equivalent confirmation for recording subscriptions and redemptions and maintaining the shareholder register (Articles 8 and 16 of CSSF Regulation No 10-4; Articles 58 and 65 of Delegated Regulation 231/2013). The 35% that did not included IFMs that had simply failed to select “Not applicable”. The CSSF’s instruction is direct: an IFM that does not act as UCI administrator within the meaning of Circular CSSF 22/811 must indicate “Not applicable” in the questionnaire.
For both groups the CSSF reiterates the importance of documenting the work, and adds that where portfolio management or the registrar and NAV functions are delegated, the IFM must ensure its delegates have suitable systems under the same articles.
Marketing, valuation and branch answers
About 9% of IFMs had no marketing procedure in 2023, down from 24% in 2021. Whether marketing is delegated or performed internally, the CSSF reiterates that each IFM must implement procedures ensuring UCIs are marketed in line with the legal and regulatory provisions in force, in particular the UCI Law and the AIFM Law. That covers initial due diligence and ongoing monitoring of the marketing intermediaries the IFM deals with directly, and the AML/CFT rules.
A small minority of AIFMs designated the depositary as external valuer: 4% in 2021, 3% in 2022 and 2% in 2023. All but one confirmed that the depositary had functionally and hierarchically separated its depositary functions from its valuation tasks and that conflicts were identified, managed, monitored and disclosed to investors, as Article 17(4) of the AIFM Law requires. The exception and its depositary ended their contract.
On segregating valuation from portfolio management, 96% of AIFMs repeatedly indicated that portfolio managers were not involved in valuation. Where some involvement existed, such as a seat on a committee without voting rights or supplying information useful for valuation, most explanations still showed segregation. The CSSF reminds the remaining AIFMs that under Article 17(4)(b) of the AIFM Law an internal valuation function is permitted only if it is functionally independent from portfolio management and the remuneration policy and other measures mitigate conflicts and prevent undue influence on employees. It also refers to its feedback report on the ESMA common supervisory action on valuation.
The share of IFMs with branches outside Luxembourg rose from 28% in 2021 to 35% in 2023, and those IFMs confirmed that their procedures covered the branches. Internal control functions must cover branch activity too. The reporting detail concerns accounting tables: under Circulars CSSF 15/633 and 10/467, an IFM with one or more branches must send version “L” of the periodic accounting tables (head office figures only) together with version “N” (head office plus all branches) and version “S” (each branch separately), as set out in Section B of the CSSF FAQ on closing documents and financial information by managers.
Triage table: requirement, expectation or recommendation
The review uses three registers of language, and they carry different weight. “Must” statements mostly restate requirements that already exist in the UCI Law, the AIFM Law, a CSSF regulation, Delegated Regulation 231/2013 or Circular 18/698; a few are instructions on how to complete the questionnaire. “Expects” and “requests” state the CSSF’s supervisory position. “Recommends”, “encourages” and “good practice” leave the choice with the IFM; my working assumption is that a documented reason for departing from them is the evidence worth keeping. The table sorts the points most likely to change an answer.
| Point | Review’s wording | Anchor: cited by the CSSF or governing provision |
|---|---|---|
| Own funds coverage controls | Procedures to calculate required own funds and eligible capital at any time; the review says the CSSF “expects” quarterly verification and that controls “must” be carried out at least quarterly | Point 44, Circular 18/698 |
| Guarantee granted, withdrawn or changed | Subject to prior notification | Point 34, Circular 18/698 |
| PII held while liability risks are covered by own funds | Insurance must not be reported in the questionnaire; any change notified | Questionnaire instruction in the review; Articles 12 and 15, Delegated Regulation 231/2013 |
| IFM and corporate UCI boards mainly the same persons | “Requests” a review; the conflict must at least be recorded and mitigated | Point 65, Circular 18/698 (itself a recommendation) |
| Executive committee meetings | At least monthly, documented in writing | Points 100 and 101, Circular 18/698 |
| Compliance monitoring plan and PRCF reporting | “Expects” a risk-based multi-year CMP; reports at least monthly to senior management, quarterly to the board | Review expectation; CMP areas refer to point 94 |
| Internal audit plan longer than three years | “Recommends” a three-year plan | Points 287 and 288, Circular 18/698 |
| AML/CFT in the internal audit mission | Internal audit tests and assesses AML/CFT policies and procedures; reports on compliance at least annually | Article 44(1) and (2), CSSF Regulation No 12-02 |
| New products and business relationships | Must maintain risk-assessment arrangements, appropriate procedures and an approval committee for new products and business relationships; the CSSF requests corrective action where these are absent | Points 353 to 355, Circular CSSF 18/698 |
| Independent director where UCIs are marketed to retail investors | “Encourages”, unless stricter rules apply | Review |
| Delegation monitoring tool | “Recommends” the tool; a register is “good practice” | Review; sub-delegation under points 422 and 423 |
| IFM that is not a UCI administrator | “Not applicable” must be indicated | Circular CSSF 22/811 definition |
| AIFM delegating portfolio management to an unauthorised, unsupervised entity | Must request prior CSSF authorisation | Article 18(1)(c), AIFM Law |
Frequently Asked Questions
We renounced one of our authorisations in December. Why does the questionnaire’s General Information section still show it?
The review’s Section XI explains that the General Information data are generated when the reports are made available to the IFM in CISERO and are not updated dynamically. Its example is an AIFM holding a Chapter 15 authorisation and an AIFM authorisation until 15 December of year N, renouncing the Chapter 15 authorisation from that date: if the reports were made available on 10 December, they show both authorisations. The CSSF says the information will be updated during the next financial year.
Does the questionnaire cover AML/CFT, given that the review discusses ML/TF risk?
Section 3 of Circular 21/789 states that the fight against money laundering and terrorist financing, addressed among others in Circular CSSF 21/788, is not covered in this questionnaire. The ML/TF references in the review attach to governance and control questions the questionnaire does ask: the new product and relationship approval procedure, the annual internal audit mission and the due diligence on marketing intermediaries. That is my reading of how the two fit together; the review itself does not reconcile them.
Our company is a Chapter 16 management company under Article 125-1. Is any of this relevant?
The company does not file the questionnaire, and Circular 21/789 reaches it only through the points on the statutory audit and the management letter. Circular 18/698, however, lists management companies under Articles 125-1 and 125-2 of Chapter 16 among the IFMs it covers. For Chapter 16 management companies governed by Article 125-1, Part VI, Chapter 1 of Circular CSSF 18/698 (points 597 to 599) specifies the conditions: point 598 makes named parts of Part II applicable, among them section 4.2.4 on meetings with the monthly meeting rule in point 100, and point 599 applies the AML/CFT sub-chapter 5.4.
Part II, which contains the internal audit plan rule in point 287, is written for IFMs authorised under Articles 101 and 125-2 of the 2010 Law or under the 2013 Law, and point 598 does not list its section 5.3.3 on internal audit. Point 601 applies “Part VI, Chapter 1 or Part II, where appropriate” to Chapter 17 branches, whereas point 604 applies the entire Parts II, V, VIII and IX to SIAGs and FIAAGs, except point 512, and disapplies sections 5.3.2 (compliance) and 5.3.3 (internal audit) to SIAGs. My reading is that the monthly meeting rule reaches an Article 125-1 company and point 287 does not.
The IFM was withdrawn from the CSSF’s official list during the year. Is a questionnaire still due?
Yes. Section 3 of the circular requires a questionnaire covering the period from the last year-end to the date of withdrawal or deregistration, in principle within the same four months. Section 4.3 applies the same logic to the separate report, in principle within seven months.
Our REA found nothing worth raising. Is a management letter still filed?
Yes. Under section 4.2 of Circular 21/789 the REA still validates the management letter form in eDesk, using the field provided to state that no issue was raised (“No comment ML”), and the IFM’s responsible persons submit it within seven months after year-end. Where the letter does contain points, each must carry the responsible persons’ comments, including the reasons for the weakness and the remediation measures with a plan and timetable. Where the responsible persons do not remedy the points raised in a timely manner and within a reasonable time frame, the circular has the REA issue the letter stating that no comments were received from them.
Our internal audit plan covers one year. Does the CSSF’s recommendation apply to us?
The explicit recommendation targets plans longer than three years. The review records the 16% of IFMs with one-year plans without a separate recommendation for them.
Point 287 of Circular CSSF 18/698 requires an internal audit plan covering several years, generally three. A stand-alone one-year plan does not satisfy that multi-year requirement. Approval by senior management and the management body under point 288 does not remove the requirement to maintain a multi-year plan. The plan should be reviewed annually and adapted where appropriate.
Can the REA’s separate report end up contradicting our questionnaire answers?
Testing those answers is part of its purpose. Section 4.3 of the circular says the separate report exists to ensure the reliability of the answers the IFM gave in the questionnaire and to answer a set of questions set by the CSSF. The REA performs procedures defined by the CSSF and records the results mainly as answers to closed-ended questions; the report does not contain an opinion under auditing, assurance or related services standards.
Related Articles
- CSSF Illiquid Asset Valuation Review: What Luxembourg IFMs Must Address: the CSSF’s 2026 feedback on valuation policies, models and controls for less liquid and illiquid assets.
- ESMA Risk Management Function CSA: The 2026-2027 Supervisory Review: how national supervisors are testing the risk management function of UCITS management companies and AIFMs.
- CSSF White-Label Business Notification: What the New Form Asks: which Luxembourg IFMs file the white-label form and what it asks on conflicts and fees.
- CSSF Long Form Report 2027: What the SAQ Asks of Banks and Auditors: the bank-side self-assessment questionnaire and REA reports under Circular CSSF 22/821.
- CSSF Circular 26/915: DORA Circulars Re-Mapped for Third-Country Branches: the 2026 amendment that also updated Circular CSSF 25/882 on ICT third-party services.
Key Takeaways
- Give each “must” row in the triage table an evidence file (minutes, control logs, notification receipts) before the questionnaire goes to the responsible persons for validation.
- Minute a decision on each “recommends” or “encourages” item the IFM does not follow, so the reasoning exists when the answer is questioned.
- If the conflicts of interest record showed no entries for 2026, run it against the CSSF’s example list before the year-end answers are drafted.
- Tell the REA early about any answer changed after reading the review, since the separate report tests the questionnaire’s reliability.
- Where group internal audit serves the IFM, check that its scope and summary report are dedicated to the IFM before the five-month filing.
- A branch opened since the last filing changes two things at once: control-function coverage and the L, N and S versions of the accounting tables.
Sources and References
- CSSF, Thematic Review: Self-assessment questionnaires submitted by IFMs relating to Circular CSSF 21/789 (as amended by Circular CSSF 23/839), Findings and recommendations, published 20 November 2026: publication page
- Thematic review, English PDF: https://www.cssf.lu/wp-content/uploads/Thematic_Review_Reports_Circular_CSSF_21_789_EN.pdf
- Thematic review, French PDF: https://www.cssf.lu/wp-content/uploads/Thematic_Review_Reports_Circular_CSSF_21_789_FR.pdf
- Circular CSSF 21/789 (as amended by Circular CSSF 23/839), CSSF document page: https://www.cssf.lu/en/Document/circular-cssf-21-789/
- Circular CSSF 21/789, English PDF: https://www.cssf.lu/wp-content/uploads/cssf21_789eng.pdf
- Circular CSSF 23/839 of 26 July 2023, with Circular 21/789 as amended in annex: https://www.cssf.lu/wp-content/uploads/cssf23_839eng.pdf
- Circular CSSF 18/698 on the authorisation and organisation of IFMs: https://www.cssf.lu/en/Document/circular-cssf-18-698/
- Circular CSSF 25/882 (as amended by Circular CSSF 26/915) on ICT third-party services for DORA entities: https://www.cssf.lu/en/Document/circular-cssf-25-882/
- CSSF FAQ on the submission of closing documents and financial information by managers: https://www.cssf.lu/wp-content/uploads/FAQ-IFM-documents_en.pdf
- CSSF, Reports foreseen by Circulars CSSF 21/788, 21/789 and 21/790 applicable as from year end 31 December 2023 now available in eDesk (15 November 2023): CSSF communication
- Circular CSSF 22/821 (as amended by Circulars CSSF 23/845, CSSF 24/865 and CSSF 25/897) on the Long Form Report self-assessment questionnaire for credit institutions: https://www.cssf.lu/en/Document/circular-cssf-22-821/
- CSSF Regulation No 12-02 of 14 December 2012 on the fight against money laundering and terrorist financing: https://www.cssf.lu/wp-content/uploads/RCSSF_No12-02eng.pdf
- CSSF Regulation No 10-4 (organisational requirements, conflicts of interest, conduct of business and risk management for UCITS management companies): https://www.cssf.lu/wp-content/uploads/RCSSF_No10-04_eng.pdf
- Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) No 231/2013 (AIFMD Level 2): https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:32013R0231
- ESMA, launch of the common supervisory action on the risk management function: https://www.esma.europa.eu/press-news/esma-news/esma-launches-common-supervisory-action-ncas-risk-management-function
Before the FY2026 questionnaire is validated
The review gives the responsible persons a published benchmark to validate the next answers against, section by section, and it shows the CSSF reading the free-text explanations behind negative answers in the IT systems and valuation sections. For a 31 December 2026 year-end the questionnaire is due by 30 April 2027 and the REA’s separate report and management letter by 31 July 2027 (my count from the four-month and seven-month rules). The step to schedule now is a pre-validation pass over the own funds, conflicts record, internal audit plan and “Not applicable” answers, finished before the board meeting that signs off the FY2026 questionnaire.
Disclaimer: The information on RegReportingDesk.com is for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal, regulatory, tax, or compliance advice. Always consult your compliance officer, legal counsel, or the relevant supervisory authority for guidance specific to your institution.
