FR Y-8 Reporting: Section 23A Transactions and the Peak-Day Figure
Each quarter, the top-tier holding company of a U.S. insured bank or savings association has 30 calendar days to tell the Federal Reserve how much business that institution did with its affiliates under section 23A of the Federal Reserve Act. The return is the FR Y-8, the Holding Company Report of Insured Depository Institutions’ Section 23A Transactions with Affiliates (OMB control number 7100-0126, approved to 31 March 2028). FR Y-8 reporting runs one insured institution at a time, and Part I items 1 to 4 and 7 each ask for two figures: the balance at quarter-end and the largest end-of-day balance during the quarter.
The second figure is the operational problem. Column B of Part I and Memorandum item 1 can only be produced from a daily series of end-of-day totals, split by whether each covered transaction falls under the section 23A collateral rules and whether the counterparty is a financial subsidiary. A ledger that reconciles intercompany positions only at quarter-end cannot supply them. The Board’s 2025 renewal notice counted 590 respondents and 12,178 burden hours a year for a three-page form.
Related reading: FR Y-9C Reporting: The $3 Billion Line and the 40-Day Clock
Legal basis of the FR Y-8: section 23A, Regulation W and three reporting statutes
Two sets of law sit behind the report. The first creates the reporting duty. Page 1 of the current form cites section 5(c) of the Bank Holding Company Act of 1956 (12 U.S.C. 1844(c)), section 10(b)(2) of the Home Owners’ Loan Act (12 U.S.C. 1467a(b)(2)) and section 8(a) of the International Banking Act (12 U.S.C. 3106(a)). The Board’s 2022 supporting statement maps them to filers: the Bank Holding Company Act provision reaches bank holding companies and intermediate holding companies, the Home Owners’ Loan Act provision reaches savings and loan holding companies, and the International Banking Act provision reaches foreign banking organizations that directly own or control a U.S. subsidiary insured depository institution. The Board’s report page states that participation is mandatory.
The second set defines what gets measured. Section 23A (12 U.S.C. 371c) caps the covered transactions of a member bank and its subsidiaries with any single affiliate at 10 percent of the bank’s capital stock and surplus, and with all affiliates combined at 20 percent. The Board implements the section through Regulation W, 12 CFR Part 223. Section 23A is written for member banks, but section 18(j) of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. 1828(j)(1)(A)) applies it to every nonmember insured bank as if it were a member bank, and section 11 of the Home Owners’ Loan Act (12 U.S.C. 1468(a)(1)) applies it to every savings association. I read those two extensions as the reason one form can speak of insured depository institutions throughout, whatever their charter.
Collateral is the other statutory rule the form tracks. Regulation W requires each credit transaction with an affiliate to be secured, at the time of the transaction, by collateral with a market value of at least 100 percent of the amount for U.S. government and agency obligations and the other listed types (including a segregated, earmarked deposit account), 110 percent for obligations of a State or political subdivision, 120 percent for other debt instruments including loans and receivables, and 130 percent for stock, leases and other real or personal property (12 CFR 223.14(b)). The codified regulation still applies that test at the time of the transaction, but section 608 of the Dodd-Frank Act amended the statute, with effect from 21 July 2012, to require the credit to be secured at all times and to extend the requirement to credit exposure from securities borrowing or lending and derivative transactions with an affiliate (12 U.S.C. 371c(c)(1)).
The FR Y-8 instructions, on a line item page dated June 2018, still say that covered transactions with a single financial subsidiary may reach 20 percent of capital stock and surplus, with financial subsidiaries counted inside the 20 percent aggregate for all affiliates. Section 609 of the Dodd-Frank Act struck that exception from section 23A with effect from 21 July 2012, for covered transactions entered into on or after 21 July 2010, so under the statute a financial subsidiary is held to the 10 percent single-affiliate limit like any other affiliate. The codified Regulation W text (12 CFR 223.32(a)) still carries the old exception.
One design choice stands out for anyone used to capital returns. No FR Y-8 line asks for capital stock and surplus, and none computes how much of the 10 or 20 percent limit is in use. The glossary defines capital stock and surplus by reference to the institution’s most recent Call Report, yet the report carries dollar amounts only. The limits bind the bank, and the holding company files the numbers.
Who must report the FR Y-8: top-tier holding companies, FBOs and quarters with no transactions
The General Instructions put the obligation on every top-tier bank holding company, financial holding company, intermediate holding company and savings and loan holding company that owns or controls an insured depository institution with any section 23A transactions with its affiliates. A separate FR Y-8 is filed for each insured institution that has such transactions. A holding company whose insured institutions have none does not file, and the Board’s 2022 supporting statement applies that test quarter by quarter: no report is due for a subsidiary institution that conducted no section 23A covered transactions with an affiliate in that quarter. Read that alongside the line item note that, in general, covered transactions are reported for as long as they remain on the institution’s books: on my reading, a covered transaction booked in an earlier quarter and still outstanding keeps the institution in the report.
The instruction book sets no asset-size threshold. A small savings and loan holding company whose bank holds one non-exempt loan to its parent files; a large group whose bank had no covered transactions with any affiliate during a quarter files nothing for that bank. The trigger is the presence of covered transactions.
Foreign banking organizations come in through a separate paragraph. The instructions say all “qualified” foreign banking organizations that own a U.S. subsidiary bank must file. Where a multi-tiered foreign group has a domestic holding company below the foreign parent, the domestic holding company files for every insured institution it owns directly or indirectly, and the foreign banking organization files only for a U.S. subsidiary bank it owns directly. The instruction book does not define “qualified” for this purpose. The Board’s report page describes the population as foreign banking organizations that directly own a U.S. subsidiary bank, and its 2024 and 2025 Federal Register notices as those that directly own or control a U.S. subsidiary insured depository institution, neither using that word. Our FR Y-7Q guide for foreign banking organizations covers a separate Board report filed by foreign banking organizations.
The definitions in the glossary and General Instructions settle most boundary questions:
| Entity | How the FR Y-8 treats it |
|---|---|
| Insured depository institution with covered transactions with affiliates in the quarter | One FR Y-8 per institution, filed by the top-tier holding company |
| Insured institution that is a subsidiary of another insured institution | Its own separate FR Y-8 |
| Subsidiaries of the insured institution, other than financial subsidiaries, insured institution subsidiaries and certain ESOP and joint venture subsidiaries | Their transactions with affiliates are included in the institution’s report |
| Financial subsidiary of the insured institution | An affiliate; reported through items 3 to 7 |
| Insured branch or agency of a foreign bank | Outside the definition of insured depository institution for this report |
| Uninsured trust company | Not required to complete the report |
The population is fixed at quarter-end. The holding company reports only for insured institutions, and their subsidiaries, that are part of its organizational structure on the last calendar day of the quarter, and the institution’s legal name has to match the name on the Report of Changes in Organizational Structure (FR Y-10).
What the report contains: Part I covered transactions, Memorandum item 1 and Part II derivatives
The form has three pages. Page 1 carries the holding company’s legal title and mailing address, a contact name with phone, fax and e-mail, and an attestation by an authorized officer that the report was prepared in conformance with the Federal Reserve’s instructions and is true and correct to the best of the officer’s knowledge and belief. Page 2 names the insured institution and holds Part I. Page 3 holds Part II.
Part I opens with two check boxes that switch blocks of lines off. Check box 1 is ticked when the institution’s covered transactions are with financial subsidiaries only, and items 1 and 2 are then left blank. Check box 2 is ticked when the institution does not control a financial subsidiary, and items 3 to 7 are left blank. Every respondent completes Memorandum item 1. The line item instructions direct Part I at each institution that has covered transactions with affiliates or that controls a financial subsidiary.
Part I line items
| Item | What it captures | Columns |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Covered transactions with affiliates subject to the section 23A collateral requirements, excluding financial subsidiaries | A and B |
| 2 | Covered transactions with affiliates not subject to the collateral requirements, excluding financial subsidiaries | A and B |
| 3 | Covered transactions with financial subsidiaries subject to the collateral requirements, excluding items 5 and 6 | A and B |
| 4 | Covered transactions with financial subsidiaries not subject to the collateral requirements, excluding items 5 and 6 | A and B |
| 5.a, 5.b | The institution’s purchase of, or investment in, equity securities (excluding retained earnings) and debt securities issued by financial subsidiaries | A only |
| 6.a, 6.b | Affiliates’ purchase of, or investment in, equity securities (excluding retained earnings) and debt securities issued by those financial subsidiaries | A only |
| 7 | Loans or other extensions of credit by affiliates to the institution’s financial subsidiaries, not subject to section 23A | A and B |
| Memorandum 1 | Maximum aggregate of all covered transactions in items 1 to 6 for any single day of the quarter | One amount |
Column A is the outstanding aggregate amount at the report date. Column B is the maximum aggregate amount during the calendar quarter ending with the report date, and the instructions define it narrowly: determine an end-of-day total for the line’s category on each day and report only the largest one. Memorandum item 1 applies the same single-day logic to items 1 to 6 combined, leaving out item 7.
That definition fixes how Memorandum item 1 has to be built. Adding up the column B figures for items 1 to 4 produces a number no single day may have reached, because each line can peak on a different day. Quality edit 0350 in the instruction book is built around this: for banks, where Memorandum item 1 is positive and equals none of items 1B to 4B, the sum of those column B figures should not equal Memorandum item 1. I take the edit to be aimed at filers who summed the peaks instead of computing the daily aggregate.
Sorting items 1 and 2: the collateral split
The split between items 1 and 2, and between items 3 and 4, follows the statute. Loans and extensions of credit to an affiliate, and guarantees, acceptances or letters of credit issued on behalf of an affiliate (including relevant credit derivatives), are generally subject to the section 23A collateral requirements. These transactions belong in item 1 when they involve affiliates other than financial subsidiaries, or in item 3 when they involve financial subsidiaries of the insured institution or affiliated insured depository institutions, subject to applicable exemptions and the separate securities-investment reporting in items 5 and 6. Purchases of or investments in affiliate securities generally belong in item 2 when they are not subject to section 23A collateral requirements. However, an insured institution’s purchase of debt securities issued by an affiliate is treated as an extension of credit and generally must be collateralised unless the securities were purchased from a nonaffiliate in a bona fide secondary-market transaction. For debt securities issued by affiliates other than financial subsidiaries, the line item text does not state the mapping, but the item definitions point collateral-bearing purchases to item 1 and qualifying bona fide secondary-market purchases to item 2, unless another exemption applies.
Purchases of debt securities issued by the insured institution’s financial subsidiaries, or financial subsidiaries of affiliated insured depository institutions, are reported separately: item 5.b for purchases by the insured institution and item 6.b for purchases by its affiliates. These financial-subsidiary securities purchases are excluded from items 1 to 4. Purchases of assets from affiliates and acceptance of affiliate securities as collateral for third-party credit generally belong in item 2 when the relevant affiliate is not a financial subsidiary. Where the covered transaction involves a financial subsidiary, item 4 applies instead, subject to applicable exemptions and the separate treatment of securities investments in items 5 and 6.
The instructions’ list of covered transactions not subject to the collateral requirements still includes purchases of assets subject to an agreement to repurchase. Section 608 of the Dodd-Frank Act amended the statute, with effect from 21 July 2012, to include such a purchase in the loan or extension of credit limb of the covered-transaction definition (12 U.S.C. 371c(b)(7)(A)), and section 23A requires each loan or extension of credit to an affiliate to be secured at all times (12 U.S.C. 371c(c)(1)). Whether a repurchase-style purchase belongs in item 1 or item 2 (item 3 or item 4 for a financial subsidiary) is a point to confirm with the district Reserve Bank.
Lines of credit straddle both. The drawn portion of a line of credit to an affiliate is an extension of credit subject to the section 23A collateral requirements and is reported in item 1 for affiliates other than financial subsidiaries, or item 3 for financial subsidiaries. Where the institution has no legal obligation to advance further funds until the required collateral is provided, the unused portion is not subject to the collateral requirements and is reported in item 2 for other affiliates, or item 4 for financial subsidiaries. The instructions do not say where an undrawn amount goes when that condition fails.
Financial subsidiary lines and item 7
Items 3 to 7 apply only where the institution controls a financial subsidiary: in the glossary’s terms, a subsidiary engaged in activities that national banks may not conduct directly, or conduct on different terms, and that a federal statute (other than 12 U.S.C. 24a) does not expressly authorize a national bank to own. The glossary carves out subsidiaries engaged solely in selling insurance as agent or broker, and certain state bank subsidiaries that count as financial subsidiaries only because of activities the state bank may conduct directly on the same terms, or activities the subsidiary was authorized to conduct before 12 December 2002 and lawfully conducted on that date. For items 5.a and 6.a, the form and instructions exclude certain retained earnings of the financial subsidiary when measuring the equity investment, with a reference to 12 CFR 223.32(b). Section 609 of the Dodd-Frank Act struck the statutory exception for earnings retained by financial subsidiaries from section 23A with effect from 21 July 2012, so the amount reported in items 5.a and 6.a may differ from the amount that counts against the statutory limits.
Item 7 is the odd line. Credit extended by other affiliates to the financial subsidiary is outside the institution’s section 23A limits but is still reported, unless the credit is treated as regulatory capital of the financial subsidiary, in which case the instructions treat it as an extension of credit by the institution itself and send it to item 3.
Part II derivatives
Part II has three quarter-end lines for each institution that has engaged in derivative transactions with affiliates, financial subsidiaries included: the positive fair value of derivative contracts where an affiliate is the counterparty, the market value of collateral pledged to the institution to secure them, and the gross notional amount, which should equal the total notional of contracts with positive and negative fair values. Contracts with the same counterparty that meet the right-of-setoff criteria in ASC Subtopic 210-20 may be netted for the fair value line. The glossary, on a page dated June 2009, keeps credit exposure from these derivatives outside the section 23A quantitative and collateral requirements on a stated condition: the institution establishes and maintains policies and procedures designed to manage the exposure. Section 608 of the Dodd-Frank Act has since changed the statute: with effect from 21 July 2012, a derivative transaction with an affiliate is a section 23A covered transaction to the extent it causes credit exposure to the affiliate, and that exposure must be secured by collateral at all times (12 U.S.C. 371c(b)(7)(G) and (c)(1)). The form still collects these positions in Part II, so how they count against the limits is a point to confirm with the district Reserve Bank.
One derivative belongs in Part I. A credit derivative under which the institution protects a nonaffiliate against default on, or a decline in value of, an obligation of an affiliate counts as a guarantee on behalf of the affiliate, and the instructions place it in Part I as a covered transaction and exclude it from Part II.
Units, signs and blanks
Amounts are reported in thousands of dollars, rounded to the nearest thousand, and items under $500 should be reported as zero. The report is prepared under GAAP and the instructions. The Reporting Central FR Y-8 user guide allows positive, zero or null values in financial fields, written without dollar signs or commas, up to 14 digits and no decimal places; the two check boxes are entered as 1 or 0. Captions on the form cannot be changed, and an entry (an amount or a zero) is required on items 1 and 2 unless check box 1 is ticked, on items 3 to 7 unless check box 2 is ticked, and on Memorandum item 1 in every case. For valuation the instructions point to Regulation W (12 CFR 223.21 to 223.24): in general a covered transaction is reported for as long as it remains on the institution’s books, and the reported value reflects amortization or depreciation of assets and repayment or retirement of loans.
FR Y-8 reporting deadlines: four quarter-end report dates and a 30-day receipt window
The report is prepared as of 31 March, 30 June, 30 September and 31 December. The submission date is 30 calendar days after the report date, and the instructions define it as the date by which the Federal Reserve must receive the report, by the end of the reporting day (5:00 p.m. at each district Reserve Bank). A deadline falling on a Saturday, Sunday or holiday moves to the first business day after it. The instructions encourage earlier submission and state that no extensions of time are granted.
A holding company that controls an insured institution with more than one foreign office, other than a “shell” branch or an International Banking Facility, may take an additional fifteen days. The instructions word that allowance as something the holding company may take, with no request step described. The Board’s 2022 supporting statement describes the same 15 days as an extension that “may be granted”, so the two documents frame it differently.
| Report date | 30th calendar day | 45th calendar day (foreign-office condition met) |
|---|---|---|
| 31 March | 30 April | 15 May |
| 30 June | 30 July | 14 August |
| 30 September | 30 October | 14 November |
| 31 December | 30 January | 14 February |
The dates are my own count of calendar days from each report date; any of them moves to the next business day when it lands on a weekend or holiday. Put simply, the report for a quarter that has just closed is due on the 30th day of the following month, and the measurement window for column B and Memorandum item 1 is the whole calendar quarter ending with the report date.
The instructions set out no separate first-filing rule for a new holding company or a newly acquired bank. They tie the population to the organizational structure on the last calendar day of the quarter, which on a plain reading makes the first report date the first quarter-end at which the institution sits inside the structure and has covered transactions with an affiliate.
Submission through Reporting Central: file format, signature and amended reports
All holding companies must submit the FR Y-8 electronically, and the instructions send filers to their district Reserve Bank or to the Reporting Central pages on FRBservices.org for the procedures. The report goes to the Federal Reserve Bank that receives the holding company’s FR Y-9C, FR Y-9SP or Annual Report of Foreign Banking Organizations (FR Y-7), regardless of where the insured institution is located. Smaller holding companies that file parent-only statements will find the FR Y-9SP, the report whose Reserve Bank also takes their FR Y-8, in our FR Y-9LP and FR Y-9SP guide.
The FR Y-8 moved to the updated Reporting Central application in the first migration wave, 24 to 26 October 2025, and the Federal Reserve’s report series migration status update lists it as migrated. It is not marked among the reports switching to an XML upload format. The Reporting Central FR Y-8 user guide, dated October 2025, offers two routes: a text file built with the File Upload steps in the Reporting Central general user guide, or data entry. Each item is identified by its eight-character MDRM code: BIDIB966 and BIDIB967 for the check boxes, BIDIB968 to BIDIB981 for Part I, BIDIC450 for Memorandum item 1 and BIDIC451 to BIDIC453 for Part II. Text fields have their own length limits, 72 characters for the legal names and 2 for a state code. The user guide describes no XBRL or XML schema for this report.
Documents to keep on file for each FR Y-8 cycle
| Document | Version in force | What it governs |
|---|---|---|
| FR Y-8 instructions | Cover “Effective April 2020”; pages dated June 2009 to March 2024 | Scope, deadlines, line items, glossary, edit checklist |
| FR Y-8 reporting form | Page 1 dated 03/2025; pages 2 and 3 dated 06/2018 | Captions, MDRM codes, attestation, OMB approval to 31 March 2028 |
| Reporting Central FR Y-8 user guide | October 2025 | Text-file and data-entry submission, field types and lengths |
| Regulation W (12 CFR Part 223) | Current codified text | Covered transactions, exemptions, collateral, valuation |
The signature stays with the holding company. Page 1 must be signed by an authorized officer, and by signing the officer acknowledges that any knowing and willful misrepresentation or omission of a material fact constitutes fraud in the inducement and may expose the officer to sanctions under 18 U.S.C. 1001 and 1007. The instructions require the holding company to keep in its files a manually signed and attested printout of the data submitted, and say page 1 of the Reserve Bank-supplied form should carry the signature and attestation and be attached to that printout. The user guide’s text fields include the officer’s printed name, title and signature date but no signature itself, and the Board’s 2022 supporting statement says a signature is not submitted electronically and describes a three-year retention period. The instruction book names no retention period.
The Federal Reserve regards each respondent’s institution-level information as confidential, the Board’s report page describes the microdata as confidential, and the 2022 supporting statement cites exemptions 4 and 8 of the Freedom of Information Act. If information later has to be released, the instructions say respondents will be notified. Two follow-up powers sit in the General Instructions: the Federal Reserve may require additional information from the insured institution through the holding company where the FR Y-8 is not sufficient to determine compliance, and it may require amended reports where a submitted report contains significant errors. Neither the instruction book nor the user guide sets out resubmission mechanics or a deadline for an amended report.
Validation: the FR Y-8 validity and quality edits that flag a filing
The edit checklist is printed at the back of the instruction book: validity edits headed with an effective date of 30 June 2019, and quality and intraseries edits headed 30 June 2018. The validity checklist states that each edit must balance and that rounding errors are not allowed. Validity edits are written as “must” tests and quality and intraseries edits as “should” tests. The instruction book does not explain how a quality-edit exception is cleared or explained to the Reserve Bank.
| Edit | Type | Test |
|---|---|---|
| 0130 to 0190 | Validity | Page 1 fields must not be null: officer’s printed name, title and signature date; contact name and title, phone, fax and e-mail |
| 0040, 0050, 0060 | Validity | Banks cannot tick both check boxes; a ticked check box 1 requires items 1 and 2 to be null; a ticked check box 2 requires items 3 to 7 to be null |
| 0041, 0056 | Validity | Thrifts: check box 1 entered as 0 and check box 2 entered as 1 |
| 0065, 0075, 0085, 0095, 0105 | Validity | Column A must not exceed column B for items 1 and 2 (all filers) and items 3, 4 and 7 (banks) |
| 0110 | Validity | If Memorandum item 1 equals zero, Part II items 1 to 3 must not be null or zero |
| 0115 | Validity | A positive fair value in Part II item 1 requires a positive notional in item 3 |
| 0400, 0401 | Quality | The column A total of the Part I covered-transaction lines should not exceed Memorandum item 1 |
| 0500, 0525 | Quality | Collateral pledged should not exceed notional; positive fair value should lie between zero and 20 percent of notional |
| 0050, 0075 | Intraseries | Each check box should match its value in the previous quarter |
Three of these turn on fields and flags before any amount is tested. The fax number is a required field under edit 0180, so a contact block without one fails validity. Edits 0041 and 0056 mean a savings association’s report always runs through items 1 and 2 with check box 2 ticked; in the edit logic, the financial-subsidiary block is closed to thrifts.
Edit 0110 was added with effect from 30 June 2019. Its descriptive text requires Part II items 1 to 3 to be non-null and non-zero when Memorandum item 1 is zero. However, the printed test expression uses “or” between the null and zero comparisons, rather than “and”. The checklist therefore does not conclusively establish how Reporting Central implements this validation; the handling of all-zero submissions should be confirmed with the district Reserve Bank.
The quality edits on items 5 and 6 work as a double-counting screen. For banks, a positive amount in any of items 5.a to 6.b should not equal the amount in item 3A or 4A, and neither should their sum. Amounts reported in items 5 and 6 are excluded from items 3 and 4 by the instructions, and the edits look for the same figure entered twice. Edit 0400 approaches the daily series from the other side: the quarter-end total in column A is one of the days in the quarter, so it should never exceed the single-day maximum in Memorandum item 1.
Caveats and interactions: exempt transactions, capital stock and surplus, and neighbouring reports
Exempt covered transactions stay off the report. The glossary lists the covered transactions that are exempt from the section 23A quantitative limits and “should not be included on this report”, and three of them carry conditions that need testing each quarter:
- Sister-bank transactions: transactions with an insured institution that controls 80 percent or more of the reporting institution’s voting shares, in which the reporting institution controls 80 percent or more of the voting shares, or whose voting shares are 80 percent or more controlled by the company that controls 80 percent or more of the reporting institution. Below the 80 percent line, the exemption is unavailable.
- Credit that is and remains fully secured by U.S. government or agency obligations, obligations fully guaranteed by them as to principal and interest, or a segregated, earmarked deposit account held with the institution for the sole purpose of securing covered transactions. Credit secured by municipal bonds or by loans can satisfy the collateral rule at 110 or 120 percent and still belongs in item 1.
- Intraday extensions of credit under 12 CFR 223.42(l), which the line item instructions also say should not be reported. Regulation W conditions that exemption on policies and procedures to manage the exposure and on the bank having no reason to expect repayment difficulty, and the bank must stop treating the credit as intraday at the end of its U.S. business day.
The glossary also keeps general purpose credit card transactions off the report unless 25 percent or more of the total value of products and services purchased with the card comes from affiliates of the institution, and exempts riskless principal and agency transactions that meet 12 CFR 223.16. In the other direction, it pulls in transactions with a third party whose proceeds are used for the benefit of, or transferred to, an affiliate. Its example is a bank loan to a customer buying a car from a dealership controlled by the same individual who controls the bank.
Capital stock and surplus has two definitions in the glossary, and the community bank leverage ratio (CBLR) decides which applies. For an institution outside the CBLR framework it is the sum of tier 1 and tier 2 capital, the allowance for credit losses not included in tier 2, and any investment in a financial subsidiary that counts as a covered transaction and is deducted from regulatory capital, with the capital and allowance amounts taken from the most recent Call Report. For a qualifying community banking organization under the framework in 12 CFR 217.12, it is tier 1 capital plus the allowance for loan and lease losses or the adjusted allowance for credit losses, as applicable. For FR Y-8 purposes, a bank that opts into or out of the CBLR framework changes the applicable calculation of capital stock and surplus used as the section 23A denominator, although the resulting numerical amount need not change. Our update on the CBLR changes in the FR Y-9C covers the framework itself, and our FFIEC Call Report guide covers the report the definition draws on.
The FR Y-8 covers section 23A only. Section 23B’s market-terms standard (12 U.S.C. 371c-1), which Regulation W implements in Subpart F, has no line on the form. The extra affiliate restrictions that section 11 of the Home Owners’ Loan Act places on savings associations, including the bar on lending to an affiliate unless it engages only in activities described in 12 U.S.C. 1467a(c)(2)(F)(i), have no separate line either. On the other side of these transactions, the glossary’s own example of an affiliate controlled by the bank’s parent is the domestic and foreign nonbanking subsidiaries of a bank holding company.
The instruction book contains no transitional provisions, size-based simplifications or waiver procedure. Proportionality comes only from the check boxes, which close the blocks of lines that do not apply to a given institution.
Recent changes to the FR Y-8 and the next approval date
The last two renewals, in 2022 and 2025, were both without revision, and the changes that did land in recent years were in definitions, edits, the form’s administrative text and the filing channel. The Board’s report page dates the FR Y-8 to March 1975.
| Date | Change | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 2018 | Declaration page eliminated; the General Instructions and Part I and II form pages carry June 2018 dates | Board report page; current form and instructions |
| 30 June 2019 | Validity edit 0110 added: its descriptive text requires Part II amounts when Memorandum item 1 is zero | Instruction book edit checklist |
| April 2020 | Instruction book cover dated “Effective April 2020”; the glossary page of that date carries the CBLR definition of capital stock and surplus | Current and archived instruction books |
| March 2024 | The March 2024 glossary states that, for institutions outside the community bank leverage ratio framework, capital stock and surplus includes the allowance for credit losses not included in Tier 2 capital | Current FR Y-8 instructions, glossary GL-2 (March 2024) |
| 7 February 2025 | Board approval of a three-year extension without revision announced (notice dated 4 February 2025), after a 60-day notice of 2 October 2024 (89 FR 80241) drew no comments | 90 FR 9158 |
| March 2025 | Form page 1 revised: approval to 31 March 2028; authority now cites the Bank Holding Company Act, Home Owners’ Loan Act and International Banking Act provisions (the earlier page cited section 5(c) and Regulation Y, 12 CFR 225.5(b)); burden estimate 4.66 hours per response, previously 7.8 | Current form compared with the archived March 2024 form |
| 24 to 26 October 2025 | Moved to the updated Reporting Central application; FR Y-8 user guide dated October 2025 | Report series migration status update; user guide |
The approval printed on the current form runs to 31 March 2028, and the form states that the Federal Reserve may not conduct or sponsor a collection of information unless it displays a currently valid OMB control number. Keeping the FR Y-8 in place beyond that date therefore needs another Paperwork Reduction Act approval. The 2024 to 2025 cycle shows the route: a 60-day comment notice in the Federal Register, then a final approval notice. The Board also lists collections that are out for comment or pending implementation on its reporting forms review page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does an insured bank whose only dealings with affiliates are derivatives need an FR Y-8?
The instructions do not answer this head-on. “Who Must Report” keys the filing to section 23A transactions, while Part II applies to each institution “that has engaged in derivative transactions with affiliates”, and the glossary places credit exposure on those derivatives outside the section 23A limits on a policies-and-procedures condition, although since 21 July 2012 the statute has treated a derivative transaction with an affiliate as a covered transaction to the extent it causes credit exposure to the affiliate (12 U.S.C. 371c(b)(7)(G)). The descriptive text of validity edit 0110 accepts a zero Memorandum item 1 only when Part II items 1 to 3 are populated, although the printed test expression is ambiguous. My reading is that the edit set anticipates derivatives-only reports; whether one is required for a particular bank is a question for the district Reserve Bank.
A bank joined the group in the middle of the quarter. What period does its first column B cover?
Column B and Memorandum item 1 cover “the calendar quarter ending with the report date”, and the population is fixed by the organizational structure on the last day of that quarter. The instructions do not say whether the daily series for a first, part-quarter report starts on the first day of the quarter or on the day the bank joined the group, and neither the instruction book nor the user guide addresses acquisitions. That makes it a point to settle with the district Reserve Bank before the first report is filed.
Our foreign parent’s only U.S. banking presence is an FDIC-insured branch. Is there an FR Y-8 to file?
Not for the branch. The instructions exclude insured branches and agencies of a foreign bank from the definition of insured depository institution for this report. A foreign banking organization files the FR Y-8 only for a U.S. subsidiary bank it owns directly; where a domestic holding company sits below it, that holding company files for each insured institution it owns directly or indirectly.
Does a sale of loans by the bank to an affiliate belong on the report?
The covered-transaction list runs one way: it includes the institution’s purchase of assets from an affiliate and has no entry for sales to one. A straightforward sale by the bank therefore has no FR Y-8 line, although section 23B’s market-terms standard expressly covers the sale of securities or other assets to an affiliate. The reverse leg has its own treatment: if the bank later buys back from the affiliate a loan it originated and sold subject to a repurchase agreement or with recourse, the glossary lists that purchase among the exempt transactions that are not reported.
The extra 15 days: do they apply to every FR Y-8 the holding company files, or only to the bank with the foreign offices?
The instructions give the extra fifteen days to “any holding company that controls an insured depository institution that has more than one foreign office” and refer to “the report” without saying which one. Read literally, the condition attaches to the holding company, while the rest of the timing paragraph is framed per insured institution. The text supports either reading, which makes it a point to settle with the district Reserve Bank before a domestic-only bank’s report is filed after day 30.
We bought an affiliate’s bonds. Item 1 or item 2?
The line item instructions treat an insured institution’s purchase of debt securities issued by an affiliate as an extension of credit that must be collateralized, unless the securities were bought from a nonaffiliate in a bona fide secondary market transaction. For an affiliate that is not a financial subsidiary, I would classify a collateral-bearing direct purchase in item 1 and a qualifying bona fide secondary-market purchase in item 2, unless another exemption applies. A purchase by the insured institution of debt securities issued by a financial subsidiary belongs instead in item 5.b, while a purchase by another affiliate belongs in item 6.b. That placement is an interpretation of how the collateral rule and the item definitions fit together, since the line item text leaves the mapping unstated.
Our bank runs intraday overdrafts for an affiliate that are cleared by close of business. Do they reach column B?
Intraday extensions of credit that meet the requirements of 12 CFR 223.42(l) are exempt from the quantitative limits and collateral requirements and should not be reported. Column B is also built from end-of-day totals, so an intraday peak would not set it. The exposure that matters is an overdraft still open at the end of the U.S. business day: Regulation W requires the bank to stop treating it as intraday at that point, and I would expect it then to enter that day’s end-of-day total as an ordinary covered transaction.
Related Articles
- FR Y-9C Reporting: The $3 Billion Line and the 40-Day Clock: the consolidated holding company financial statements filed with the same Reserve Bank that receives the FR Y-8.
- FR Y-11 Reporting: Four Quarterly Tests and a 60-Day Deadline: the Board’s report on individual nonbank subsidiaries of holding companies.
- FR Y-12 Reporting: Thresholds, Schedules and the 45-Day Deadline: the Board’s report on nonfinancial equity investments held by holding companies.
- Regulation O Recordkeeping: The FR O Revisions and Who Would File: the Board’s insider-lending recordkeeping collection and its proposed revisions.
Key Takeaways
- Capture an end-of-day total for every Part I line in use from the first day of each quarter; column B and Memorandum item 1 come from that series, and summing column B peaks is the pattern quality edit 0350 looks for.
- Re-test each insured institution every quarter. The instructions state that, in general, covered transactions are reported for as long as they remain on the books, so on the reading set out above an earlier-quarter position that is still outstanding counts in the test. An institution with no section 23A transactions needs no FR Y-8, and a single non-exempt covered transaction brings it into the report.
- Diary the 30th calendar day after each quarter-end, with receipt by 5:00 p.m. at the district Reserve Bank, and rely on day 45 only where the foreign-office condition is met and its scope is confirmed.
- Keep an exemption file each quarter: 80 percent sister-bank ownership, U.S. government or segregated-deposit collateral that stays in place, and intraday credit that meets 12 CFR 223.42(l) are what keep positions off the report.
- Run the contact block (fax included), the thrift check-box combination and the column A against column B test before upload; each is a validity edit.
- File the officer-signed page 1 with a printout of the submitted data in the holding company’s records, since Reporting Central receives no signature.
- Put 31 March 2028, the OMB approval date printed on the form, on the regulatory change calendar and watch the Federal Register for the renewal notice.
Sources and References
- Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Instructions for the Preparation of Holding Company Report of Insured Depository Institutions’ Section 23A Transactions with Affiliates, Reporting Form FR Y-8 (cover “Effective April 2020”, including the edit checklist): FR Y-8 instructions (PDF)
- Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, FR Y-8 reporting form (OMB 7100-0126, approval expires 31 March 2028; page 1 dated 03/2025): FR Y-8 form (PDF)
- Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Reporting Forms, FR Y-8 report page (respondent panel, frequency, public release, background, document history): federalreserve.gov FR Y-8 page
- Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, archived FR Y-8 form listed as March 2024 (page 1 dated 03/2022): archived FR Y-8 form (PDF)
- Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, archived FR Y-8 instructions listed as March 2022: archived FR Y-8 instructions (PDF)
- Federal Reserve System, Proposed Agency Information Collection Activities; Comment Request, 89 FR 80241 (2 October 2024), FR Doc. 2024-22637: govinfo PDF
- Federal Reserve System, Agency Information Collection Activities: Announcement of Board Approval Under Delegated Authority and Submission to OMB (FR Y-8), 90 FR 9158 (7 February 2025), FR Doc. 2025-02363: govinfo PDF
- Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Supporting Statement for the FR Y-8 (2022 extension, OMB No. 7100-0126): reginfo.gov PDF
- Federal Reserve, Reporting Central User Guide, FR Y-8 (October 2025): FR Y-8 user guide (PDF)
- Federal Reserve, Reporting Central, Report Series Migration Status Update: migration status update (PDF)
- Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Reporting forms under review: federalreserve.gov review page
- Section 23A of the Federal Reserve Act, 12 U.S.C. 371c, including the notes on the 2010 amendments made by sections 608 and 609 of the Dodd-Frank Act (Pub. L. 111-203): 12 U.S.C. 371c
- Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, staff letter to Morgan Stanley Bank, N.A. on sections 23A and 23B (5 November 2012), noting that section 608 of the Dodd-Frank Act made credit exposure on a derivative transaction with an affiliate a covered transaction with effect from 21 July 2012: Federal Reserve staff letter (PDF)
- Section 23B of the Federal Reserve Act, 12 U.S.C. 371c-1: 12 U.S.C. 371c-1
- Federal Deposit Insurance Act section 18(j), 12 U.S.C. 1828(j): 12 U.S.C. 1828
- Home Owners’ Loan Act section 11, 12 U.S.C. 1468: 12 U.S.C. 1468
- Regulation W, Transactions Between Member Banks and Their Affiliates, 12 CFR Part 223: 12 CFR Part 223
- 12 CFR 223.14, collateral requirements: 12 CFR 223.14
- 12 CFR 223.42, exemptions including intraday extensions of credit: 12 CFR 223.42
Getting the next FR Y-8 to the Reserve Bank by day 30
Most of the work behind an FR Y-8 is done while the quarter is still running: the daily end-of-day series for each Part I line, the classification of every covered transaction as collateral-bearing or not, and the exempt positions documented against the glossary list. After the report date come the quarter-end list of affiliates and financial subsidiaries, the check boxes, the Part II derivative figures, the edit run and an officer’s signature on page 1, with the file in the Reserve Bank’s hands by 5:00 p.m. on the 30th calendar day after quarter-end.
Disclaimer: The information on RegReportingDesk.com is for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal, regulatory, tax, or compliance advice. Always consult your compliance officer, legal counsel, or the relevant supervisory authority for guidance specific to your institution.
